.svg?q=70&width=384&auto=webp){kind=logo}
Top 5 Easter Basket Stuffers
Our favorite treats will give you that much-needed sugar rush for the egg hunt.
Feb 25, 2025
Easter baskets are one of those traditions that work for every age - from toddlers on their first egg hunt to adults who still love waking up to a basket on Easter morning. Whether you're filling one basket or ten, the secret to a great one is the same: a thoughtful mix of sweet treats, a few surprises, and at least one item that makes the recipient feel like you really know them. Here's our complete guide to the best Easter basket stuffers, including how to build one, how many items to include, and our favorite picks from Harry & David. Baskets, with their fake grass, plastic and chocolate eggs, and other sweet treats, are synonymous with Easter. For all you DIYers out there, we have just what you need to build the perfect one for the kids, and the kids at heart. Here are our five favorite Easter basket stuffers.
What Makes a Great Easter Basket?
The best Easter baskets balance a few key elements:
- A centerpiece item (usually a chocolate bunny or standout treat)
- 2 to 3 smaller sweet treats (candy, cookies, or gourmet snacks)
- At least one non-candy item (especially for kids or adults)
- A filler that adds texture and fun (classic Easter grass, tissue paper, or shredded paper)
A great basket doesn't have to be expensive, it just needs to feel curated. When every item has a reason to be there, the basket feels personal rather than thrown together.
How to Balance Candy and Other Gifts in an Easter Basket
A good rule of thumb: aim for roughly half candy, half non-candy. For kids especially, parents appreciate a basket that isn't 100% sugar. For adults, non-candy items often become the most memorable part. The goal is a basket that feels exciting to dig through, not just a bag of candy with a bow on it.
The Best Easter Basket Stuffers for 2026
Mr. Ears the Chocolate Easter Bunny
Mr. Ears the Chocolate Easter Bunny
Shop : Mr. Ears the Milk Chocolate Easter Bunny from Harry & David
Mr. Ears the Chocolate Easter Bunny Duo from Harry & David
No Easter basket is complete without a chocolate bunny, and Mr. Ears never goes out of style. At 10 ounces of solid gourmet milk chocolate, Mr. Ears has the silliest, gigantic ears you ever did see. (Sorry, Bugs.) He's so adorable that it may be hard to devour him. Hard, but not impossible — those ears are just asking to be nibbled.
Shop : Mr. Ears the Milk Chocolate Easter Bunny from Harry & David
Mr. Ears the Chocolate Easter Bunny Duo from Harry & David
Easter cookies
Easter cookies
Shop : Easter Cookie Gift Box from Harry & David
Cookie monsters big and small won't be able to get enough of this tasty assortment. Each gift box includes 15 buttery Easter cookies in five varieties: lemon-filled flower-cutout shortbreads, pink buttercream-frosted egg-shaped cookies, and vanilla shortbreads with sanding sugar. Include them in each Easter basket you make, and any extra can be used to make cookie milk. Yes, cookie milk. You'll thank us later.
Shop : Easter Cookie Gift Box from Harry & David
Chocolate Truffles
Chocolate Truffles
Shop : Easter Truffles from Harry & David
For a step up from standard Easter candy, these truffles are it. Made in Harry & David's own Southern Oregon candy kitchen using their proprietary chocolate blend, each box includes 24 silky-smooth truffles across six flavors. This decadent chocolate is a basket centerpiece.
Shop : Easter Truffles from Harry & David
Moose Munch Premium Popcorn Classic Tin
Moose Munch Premium Popcorn Classic Tin
Shop : Moose Munch® Premium Popcorn Classic Tin from Harry & David
Easter is one of those times when it is OK to put all your eggs, or, in this case, treats, in one basket — and one of those treats should be Moose Munch. The Moose Munch Premium Popcorn Classic Tin comes with a bag each of delicious classic caramel, dark chocolate, milk chocolate, and s'mores flavors. With this many varieties, we have only one word to describe this quartet: snacktastic!
Shop : Moose Munch® Premium Popcorn Classic Tin from Harry & David
Chocolate-covered cherries
Chocolate-covered cherries
Shop : Chocolate-Covered Cherries from Harry & David
Our favorite chocolate-covered cherries and berries are sure to kick things up a notch at the egg hunt. They're crafted using sun-ripened cherries (because moon-ripened ones don't taste as sweet) that are dipped twice (which is so much better than once) in either milk or dark chocolate and then smothered in a sweet candy coating (because a salty one is an abomination). They have no connection to Easter, but they're so good that we thought they should be enjoyed during every holiday... and all days ending in Y.
Shop : Chocolate-Covered Cherries from Harry & David
Non-Candy Easter Basket Stuffers
For parents who want to limit sugar, or for adults who prefer something beyond sweets, here are the best non-candy Easter basket ideas:
- Gourmet popcorn (Moose Munch is a crowd favorite)
- Specialty teas or hot cocoa mixes
- Small books or activity kits for kids
- A gift card to their favorite store or restaurant
- A small plant or succulent
- Skincare or bath items for adults
- A puzzle or game for the whole family
The best non-candy stuffers feel intentional - they show the recipient you thought about what they'd actually enjoy, not just what fills a basket.
Affordable Easter Basket Stuffers
You don't need to spend a lot to build a great basket. Here are tips for keeping costs down without sacrificing quality:
- Focus on 3 to 4 well-chosen items rather than filling the basket with cheap filler
- Split larger items (like the Moose Munch Pick 6 Bags or a box of pears ) across multiple baskets
- A single standout item - like Mr. Ears Chocolate Bunny- can anchor a whole basket on its own
A $30 to $50 budget is plenty for a thoughtful, well-stocked Easter basket when you're strategic about what you include. Or skip the DIY and browse our Easter Gift Baskets, curated and ready to ship.
What are the best Easter basket stuffers?
The best Easter basket stuffers include a chocolate bunny, gourmet candy or cookies, a non-candy treat like popcorn, and one item tailored to the recipient's interests. Harry & David's Mr. Ears Chocolate Bunny, Easter Cookie Gift Box, Moose Munch Premium Popcorn and gourmet chocolate truffles.
an alternative to mass-market candy.
What should I put in an Easter basket?
A well-balanced Easter basket should include a centerpiece treat (like a chocolate bunny), 2 to 3 smaller sweets, at least one non-candy item, and Easter basket filler like grass or tissue paper. Aim for 4 to 8 items total depending on the recipient's age.
How do you build the perfect Easter basket?
Start with a quality basket or container, add Easter grass or filler, then layer in your items from largest to smallest. Place the centerpiece item (usually the chocolate bunny) in the back center so it's visible, then arrange smaller items in front. Finish with a bow or cellophane wrap if you're gifting it.
What are non-candy Easter basket stuffers?
Great non-candy options include gourmet popcorn, specialty teas, small books or games, gift cards, bath and skincare items, puzzles, and small plants. For kids, art supplies and activity kits work well. For adults, gourmet food items like Moose Munch or chocolate-covered cherries straddle the line between treat and non-candy gift.
What are popular Easter basket items in 2026?
Popular Easter basket stuffers in 2026 include gourmet chocolate bunnies, specialty cookie assortments, premium popcorn tins, personalized candy selections, and non-candy items like spring potted plants, games, and self-care products. There's growing interest in elevated, gourmet Easter treats as
AUTHOR
Autumn Micketti is the Assistant Manager of SEO & Content for 1-800-Flowers. Her love of music has found her writing articles for SPIN, The Siskiyou, and The Verse, and interviewing small and large artists like Mumford & Sons, Maroon 5, and The Weepies. When she's not writing about love songs or Oregold® Peaches, you can find her exploring mountains, listening to the latest album release of her current musical obsession, DJing local events, or spending time with her extended family.
